![]() |
Old Way New Way® LearningA new twist on overcoming old habitsLearning tools for rapidly improving transfer of learning and skilled performance |
|
|
![]() |
Old Way New Way® LearningA new twist on overcoming old habitsLearning tools for rapidly improving transfer of learning and skilled performance |
|

This page introduces Old Way New Way® flight instruction, including the basic theory underpinning the method, and training programs in this unique approach to flight instruction and conversion training.


Glass cockpit conversion training

Lawn bowls technique improvement

Safety training and work habit correction
As an experienced flight instructor once said, "The problem isn't learning the new: it's forgetting [unlearning] the old."
The well-documented mental mechanism of negative transfer interferes with the learning process during conversion training, creates mental confusion, increases the error rate and slows down skill acquisition.
Because the disruptive effects of negative transfer often do not show up during simulator or aircraft training, instructors and their students can be misled into believing that the training program has been effective and that the understanding and skills that were taught have transferred fully to the “real world”.
Unfortunately, the transfer of training problem is a “sleeper” in that it only shows up under certain conditions. During normal flying conditions the problem does not surface because the pilot has enough spare capacity to be able to concentrate fully on the task at hand. Under such controlled conditions the pilot is able to apply his training and consequently the training program appears to have worked.
However, during stressful periods of high activity in the cockpit the pilot is working at or near the limits of his or her mental capacity such that active concentration is disabled in favour of operation at an automated instinctive reflex level. This is when the pilot typically falls back to mental models and skills learned with previous aircraft.
These consistent errors are referred to in the aviation research literature as habit pattern errors and they are notoriously hard to eradicate. At such potentially critical moments negative transfer suddenly surfaces and training failure becomes evident.
Apart from stressful operating conditions, negative transfer also shows up during periods of prolonged inactivity when concentration lapses and pilots fall back to old ways of thinking and acting. The valuable skills acquired during situational awareness training and CRM training fail to be implemented.
The transfer of training problem makes flight training less cost- and time-effective and wastes valuable training resources. Sub-optimal transfer of training also exposes pilots, other crew members, passengers and the public to increased risk.
Until now, there was no known method of dealing with the transfer problem that meets industry requirements, i.e., is cost- and time-effective, user-friendly and above all, practical for flight instructors to use.
Old Way New Way®’s record of published research and successful workplace trials show that this novel training method can quickly and permanently overcome negative transfer, accelerate learning and reduce risk.
Old Way New Way® is the first and still the only systematic approach to applying differences training to aircraft conversion training and transition training.
Old Way New Way® is a generic teaching method that has been applied successfully to a wide range of skill correction and skill development situations and to the correction of incorrect or incomplete mental models, i.e., the correction of misconceptions and the improvement of understanding.
Published experimental studies and aviation workplace trials show that when individuals undergo conversion or transition training that incorporates Old Way New Way®, they typically experience:
• 80% improvement in skill and understanding after one training
session, i.e., trainees improve a lot faster
• no reversion or falling back to old ways, even during stressful
performance, i.e., trainees remember what they were taught.

Since 1986, Personal Best Academy has been the supplier of customised Old Way New Way® training to government and industry trainers worldwide.
Let's explore a specific instance of negative transfer, namely landing technique.
Landings are a key competency in conversion training.
Key aspects of landing technique that typically show negative transfer effects are throttle control, attitude control and flare technique.
For example, during the initial stages of converting from the Beechcraft Baron to the Learjet, students often incorrectly apply the landing technique they learned in the Baron to the Learjet.
When placed under pressure to perform or during periods of intense cockpit activity, even experienced pilots can inadvertently revert to their previous training, i.e., they apply the techniques and knowledge acquired during training in previous aircraft. Old habits die hard.
Habit pattern errors have been implicated in many aircraft incidents and disasters over the years, yet habit pattern errors are notoriously difficult to eradicate.
Experience indicates that habit pattern errors like these respond well to Old Way New Way® intervention. Published research and workplace trials show that Old Way New Way® consistently outperforms conventional transition training methods, delivering 80% or better improvement after one session, with a greatly reduced adaptation period and no reversion to old ways, i.e., no negative transfer.
A one-month workplace trial by a large commercial airline demonstrated these training benefits with flight training. Using a Learjet 45 flight simulator, flight instructors' ratings of cadets’ landing technique following technique correction with Old Way New Way® showed that, for the three target skills (throttle control, attitude control and flare technique):
Instructor feedback indicated that instructors found the method practical, effective and quick to show results.
Cadets' feedback about their Old Way New Way® training experience was also positive. Cadets commented on how this way of teaching helped them clarify the differences in landing technique and therefore enabled them to more quickly adopt and become comfortable with the new way of landing that the instructor had taught them.
Cadets also found Old Way New Way® very user friendly. Similarly, instructors commented on how suitable the method was for flight instruction.
Old Way New Way® was shown to be a very flexible and adaptable teaching tool. During one simulator session the error initially targeted for correction had to be changed to a different technique problem that suddenly became apparent, namely cross-wind landing technique. This shift of focus was effortlessly achieved and a suitable and effective correction protocol was quickly devised and implemented, on the spot.
The workplace trial results confirmed the benefits of Old Way New Way® reported in other, non-aviation, skill development settings, namely that:
• Old Way New Way® is a practical and highly effective teaching
tool that extends the capability of instructors to eliminate negative
transfer effects, accelerate learning and improve retention
• the Old Way New Way® learning method is very flexible and adaptable
and can be readily adapted to flight instruction.
Old Way New Way® Learning is a very practical and a cost- and time-effective generic teaching method that is readily incorporated into a flight instructor’s professional toolkit. It complements existing teaching methods and magnifies the impact of conversion training.
Flight instruction becomes more cost- and time-effective, students achieve better and faster, students remember what they have been taught, and risk management due to training failure and consequent negative transfer is improved.
All this makes Old Way New Way® a valuable teaching tool for all flight instructors.
Many habit pattern errors in skilled performance and mental models can benefit from Old Way New Way® intervention, for example:
The potential application of Old Way New Way® to flight training is therefore extremely broad, reinforcing the claim that this training method is a very useful generic teaching tool in the hands of experienced flight instructors.

Accident avoidance using Old Way New Way® was one of the learning innovations introduced in the three-day Robinson R22 helicopter pilot safety awareness course conducted at the Ant Hill Hotel in Mareeba, North Queensland, during January 1998.
Over 30 mustering pilots learnt how to use Old Way New Way® to correct a potentially fatal emergency situation known in the trade as "rotor stall."
The Robinson R22 helicopter has an excellent safety record. However, like any aircraft, if it is allowed to stray outside its safe flight envelope and immediate and appropriate corrective action is not applied, a situation can develop that can have serious and even fatal consequences.
In 1994 the Board of Air Safety Investigation Asia-Pacific Air Safety Journal stated that the R22 is subject to main rotor blade stall resulting from an initial state of low indicated air speed combined with low rotor rpm. A pilot who is aware of this danger can take steps to prevent it and, even if it starts to develop, can take immediate action to prevent the rapid onset of rotor stall with its potentially fatal results. Theoretically, any rotor can stall but the lightweight, low energy rotor fitted to the R22 reacts very quickly to changes in power or angle of attack, rendering the R22 more susceptible to this problem than other small piston-engined helicopters.
The sequence of events leading to rotor stall is described graphically in this example from the International Aviation Safety College Robinson Helicopter Safety Course Manual.
The remedy is to prevent engine power reducing and rotor angle of attack increasing to the point at which it is impossible to recover rotor rpm. That is, if rotor rpm is low at low IAS (as indicated by the low rotor rpm warning horn), lower the collective while simultaneously increasing throttle.
Even if rotor rpm is further reducing, power will be available to recover rotor rpm as collective is lowered. Clearly, the pilot must carefully monitor the rotor rpm recovery to ensure that the rotor is not oversped. At the higher power setting, the collective throttle mechanical link will operate to maintain rotor rpm as the pilot raises the collective to stop any descent that may be developed.
Robinson Helicopter Company has been aware of this risk for some time and describes it fully to all students on safety courses. U.S. experience has shown that the pilots who are most vulnerable to this danger are:
To reduce the risk of the low IAS low rotor rpm situation developing, the aircraft manufacturer recommends a minimum speed of 60 kts for normal flight and to avoid unecessary flying at low level, especially under 500 ft AGL.
The third high-risk group, fixed wing pilots, when faced with a low IAS low rotor rpm situation, are very likely to experience interference that can arise from old automated skill routines when they interfere with the learning of a new skill ("old habits die hard"). This "habit interference" (sometimes called "negative transfer") is one of the major causes of technique problems in experienced operators as well as novices.
Low IAS/low RRPM accidents in fixed wing pilots are caused by the automatic application of an incorrect recovery attempt (the learned skill and automatic reaction that is transferred from a previous and different ship where it may have been appropriate). As stated in Robinson Safety Notice SN-29:
Conventional wisdom says that it takes time to overcome old habits and change established skills. To continue the above example, the safety notice correctly recommends that:
It is generally accepted that emergency procedures in airplanes require that a pilot has instilled in him certain automatic reactions. Learning these reactions can take a considerable time, especially when what is required to be learned is different from or conflicts with a previously learned reaction or response to a particular situation. Changes in routine or in equipment or control configuration can present persistent obstacles to learning progress. Research studies of skill development indicate that under conventional instruction and re-training it can take up to 2,000 repetitions of the correct reaction before a skilled operator really learns (to automatic or instinctive response stage) a new skill that conflicts with a previously learned skill.
In an ideal world a pilot would undertake such extended training until it had the desired effect but all too often the pressures of earning a living preclude completion of all but the bare minimum training requirements.
A common reaction of experienced pilots and instructors to this habit interference problem that so often occurs with conventional skill training methods is to say that this is not a "training problem', in other words, that re-training will not fix it. This mistaken belief is based on the fact that:
Old Way-New Way offers a new way of looking at pilot training and re-training. Instead of blaming lack of learning progress on the instructor or on the pilot undergoing instruction, or on both, this methodology instead attributes poor learning performance and poor transfer to proactive inhibition, a well-researched brain mechanism that has been substantiated in the psychological literature for some 80 years. "Proactive inhibition" takes place whenever old learning interferes or conflicts with new learning.
For example, explaining to a helicopter pilot that his reaction to the low rpm warning horn is incorrect and hazardous, then showing him what he should be doing and then getting him to practice that over and over does little to help him change - it simply arouses proactive inhibition in his brain which then interferes with (i.e., causes a high rate of forgettingof ) the new technique the pilot is trying to learn. Under conventional methods of technique correction the pilot may even appear to improve during training sessions and can perform satisfactorily under the watchful eye of the instructor, but he typically reverts to his old incorrect technique (the previously learned automated skill routine) in the absence of supervision and in the stress of unexpected or emergency situations.
The use of proactive inhibition, a fully-researched and validated brain mechanism, as an alternative explanation of such learning difficulties takes a lot of the "heat" out of the re-training situation and is one of the reasons for the high acceptance of the method with both instructors and trainees.
Old Way / New Way is the only skill correction method that effectively deals with such interference problems and offers quick and permanent correction and transfer of skills.
The method respects the pilot's existing skills, even though some of these may cause problems, and takes him through a systematic comparison and differentiation of his "old" (incorrect) and the "new" (correct) way.
The method is based on the premise that in order to reach the future you have to first revisit the past. Notably, because it is a metacognitive approach that makes the pilot able to self-detect and self-correct errors, the method is able to achieve the rapid transfer of learning that is so elusive under more conventional skill correction techniques. At the same time, it is user friendly and easily incorporated into what pilots and instructors normally do. Old Way-New Way is ideally suited to training using flight simulators.
Unlike other skill correction methods, with Old Way-New Way there is no temporary drop in performance while the pilot is adjusting to the new technique - improvement is almost immediate. And unlike behaviour modification or operant approaches to training, Old Way-New Way does not involve cumbersome manipulation of behavioural consequences nor does it require intensive monitoring.
All this makes Old Way New Way® very cost-effective.
Although Old Way New Way® training requires that flight instructors learn to do some things differently, basically the methodology complements good teaching practice.
Old Way New Way® is not just another quick fix; it is an intelligent fix. The strong theoretical underpinnings (see below) illustrate how it works with the brain to accelerate learning, change and improvement. It does this by overcoming the powerful interference effects of prior learning, i.e., it eliminates negative transfer and shortens the typically prolonged adaptation period to change.
The Old Way New Way® learning method is meant to be used as part of a comprehensive flight training program. It is not a replacement for quality classroom instruction, simulator training and aircraft training but is an integral part of the total training program. It is a generic teaching tool that extends the capability of flight instructors to overcome negative transfer and truly accelerate learning.
In the hands of an expert flight instructor trained in Old Way New Way® this approach to conversion training can be expected to produce rapid and substantial learning gains normally not possible with traditional teaching methods.
Consequently, this accelerated learning means more material can be covered within the available training time. Furthermore, some components of training courses may be covered more quickly because competence is achieved faster. Given the ever-increasing pressure placed on available training time and resources, these potential savings become very important.
To the extent that the cadet follows the Old Way New Way® learning process faithfully, and implements the prescribed follow-up activities to reinforce learning, his progress towards competence will be accelerated, the adaptation period will be reduced and negative transfer will be greatly reduced or eliminated.
Like all quality learning activities, the Old Way New Way® learning process is a demanding and intensely personal activity that is solely the individual’s responsibility and is under the individual’s own control. With well-motivated individuals this is usually not a problem.
To this point, experience indicates that cadets are more likely to accept and permanently adopt Old Way New Way® from an instructor if they are properly informed about the method prior to its use. Briefing and debriefing cadets on Old Way New Way® is therefore highly recommended.
The Old Way New Way® Learning System is a complete instructor development package. Not only does it offer a fresh and highly plausible explanation for commonly observed negative transfer effects in flight training; it also offers a practical and time- and cost-effective solution that is easily integrated into a flight instructor’s or ground school instructor’s professional toolkit.
The potential savings in training time and the more effective use of training resources that arise from Old Way New Way® are additional benefits.
The Old Way New Way® Learning System offers an entirely new model (see below) for flight and ground school instruction and conversion training.
These and other Old Way New Way® implementation issues are covered in-depth in an Old Way New Way® training workshop.
Training workshops are especially structured to facilitate the transition to this new approach to flight instruction and to ensure the continued long-term use of the methodology by participants.
To fully understand and appreciate how old knowledge and skills can interfere with and slow down the learning of new knowledge and skills, you should now do the colour chart activity which demonstrates this powerful, universal and involuntary obstacle to learning. When you have completed the demonstration proceed to the explanation of your scores and then return to this page.
By doing the activity you experienced proactive habit interference, also known as the proactive inhibition (PI) effect and therefore better understand the powerful effects of prior learning on new learning.
From the point of view of the pilot who is trying to convert to another type, the explanation of how proactive habit interference blocks or slows down learning and adaptation is like this:
Proactive habit interference is a major cause of a wide range of negative transfer and other flight training problems including:
Now you know what the problem is and what it feels like, you are ready for the solution. Being aware of PI and it's effects, however, is not enough to overcome it. Simply re-teaching a skill or action, even when supported by specific videotaped feedback to improve awareness, is unlikely to work quickly, if at all. You need an alternative training method that bypasses habit interference altogether in order to accelerate learning and skill development. This training method is called Old Way New Way®.
Old Way New Way® can overcome flight instruction difficulties permanently and more quickly than conventional, i.e., currently available, flight training methods.
Old Way New Way® offers an entirely new approach to skill development, technique correction, conceptual change, attitude change and other flight training difficulties, whether these be physical or mental. Although highly innovative, this methodology is readily integrated into what instructors and pilots normally do in their quest for skill development and continuous improvement.
Read the published research reports, workplace trials and evaluations.
For a more recent and complete list of all Old Way New Way® research, peruse the bibliography which contains many links to full text articles.
All kinds of technique difficulties can be corrected, including physical skills as well as mental skills. These examples are drawn from elite sports coaching.
To read these case studies click on the hyperlink. After reading them, click the "Back " button on your browser to return to this page.
We have successfully corrected errors and faulty technique, unlearned habits and developed skills in a wide range of sports, for example:
Trainers, teachers, instructors and sports coaches try to get it right the first time with their students, trainees and athletes but invariably end up spending a lot of time trying to correct errors, misconceptions, non-compliance, technique faults and bad habits that somehow develop.
Because these errors were not corrected early, and were inadvertently repeated over and over (i.e., practised), many error patterns are actually learned, habitual and automatic and therefore much harder to eradicate.
For example, John always writes "recieve" instead of "receive"; Mike always has to be reminded to wear his safety goggles; Mary always slices her golf swing; Susan always follow cars too closely when driving; and Geoff is mentally still following the previous aircraft’s pre-flight checklist even though he's converted to another aircraft.
We all know that old habits die hard and many habit patterns are resistant to conventional change methods.
These limitations of traditional teaching and training programs are apparent in all settings including sport, workplace training, education, therapy and personal development.
Re-training or re-education, the typical solution to these problems, improves things only slowly, if at all.
Although learners may appear to pay attention during instruction and practice their new, correct, skills and knowledge over and over, the next day when placed under pressure or when unsupervised and left to their own devices, they seem to have forgotten what they’ve learned and the same habit pattern errors (old entrenched attitudes, beliefs, misunderstandings, work practices and routines, faulty procedures, poor techniques and unsafe behaviours) resurface.
A prolonged adjustment period and poor transfer of learning are the two most typical outcomes of education, training and coaching efforts worldwide.
All this wastes talent and resources and makes change and transition programs so much less cost-effective. There’s got to be a better way.
Fortunately, a cognitive science discovery called Old Way New Way Learning offers:
1. A new perspective on the transfer of training problem.
2. A fast and practical method of transition training.
3. A cost-effective and user-friendly method for rapid skill and technique correction, and habit eradication.
This page introduces Old Way New Way® flight instruction, including the basic theory underpinning the method, and training programs in this unique approach to flight instruction and conversion training.